Pros and cons of moving your annuity

  • If you have some investments that are not annuities (such as mutual funds) that will transfer to Fidelity, having all your investments with one company may make managing and tracking them easier. This is a personal preference in how you manage retirement savings accounts.
  • If you transfer an annuity to a mutual fund with Fidelity, you may be charged fees by the annuity insurance company to do so. This can include a surrender fee, for example. Often these surrender charges decrease over time, so you may need to wait until they expire. You’ll want to compare the costs and fees with a advisor.
Scroll down to see a list of recommended questions to ask TIAA, Corebridge and Fidelty retirement plan financial consultants

FAQ: Determining if you transfer annuities

The Informational Guide and Mapping Appendix is your best resource. To determine if you have an annuity, compare your retirement plan investment statement to the Mapping Appendix. Many investment funds have similar names, but different share classes so be sure to match your statements investments names exactly to the name in the Mapping Appendix on Fidelity’s transition website at www.myfidelitysite.com/CSU.

If you determine your investments are annuities, most of them will not transfer as a part of the transition.

  • There is not an annuity option in the new menu for investments in the defined contribution plan. But, annuities in a defined contribution plan can be transferred into mutual funds in the new menu, if you request a transfer.
  • There will be an annuity option in the 403(b) plan investment menu at Fidelity. If you choose to transfer annuities from your exiting 403(b), transferring into this annuity will be a good option for you.

You can choose to transfer annuities later or leave them where they are. A Fidelity workplace consultant can help you transfer annuities. You can reach them at 800-642-7131 or getguidance.fidelity.com to schedule a one-on-one consultation.

In June, you will no longer be able to send payroll contributions to any annuity with Corebridge, TIAA or the MetLife annuity with Fidelity.

These annuity accounts will remain where they are but will be frozen until you take distributions after you retire or unless you transfer them to a Fidelity mutual fund in the new fund structure. This means that your money will remain where it is in your current annuity, but the money both you and CSU put toward your retirement after June will no longer be made to these investments. Instead, the money from your payroll plus what CSU contributes toward your defined contribution plan for retirement will go into new mutual funds under the new structure with Fidelity. See the mapping document on Fidelity’s website for more information.

If you are in the defined contribution plan, the new high-quality menu offered for CSU retirement plans through Fidelity does not provide an option to transfer an annuity from TIAA or Corebridge into an annuity with Fidelity. There is one annuity option for 403(b) plans under the new line up.

This is because retirement plan structures are generally moving away from annuities to reduce costs and improve flexibility.

The Securities and Exchange Commission and the Internal Revenue Service have rules that restrict moving annuities from one company to another without the account holder explicitly approving the transfer in writing. This is due to additional fees you may be charged if you transfer an annuity from one company to another.

Because of these rules, CSU can’t transfer any annuities with Corebridge, TIAA or the Fidelity MetLife option for you as part of this transition. The new high-quality investment line-up now offered through this transition consists of mutual funds.

Due to legal requirements, annuities are not included as an option for defined contribution plan participants. One annuity option is available within the 403(b) investment menu.

If you want to transfer your annuities to the new investments at Fidelity, you can, but you’ll need to take some specific steps to do so. You will need to work directly with your current investment advisor or ask a Fidelity advisor to determine if this is the best option for your future retirement planning goals. There are many considerations to think about.

See our suggested questions to ask your current investment advisor with Corebridge or TIAA as well as a Fidelity representative if you have a MetLife annuity. These questions are a good place to start.  

There are many factors to consider including:

  • How close you are to retirement
  • How many years you’ve paid in annuity fees
  • If there are any surrender fees for transferring the investment to a mutual fund

Understanding these factors and their impact on your retirement income will help you assess if it financially benefits you to transfer the annuity to a mutual fund in the CSU core fund line-up at Fidelity. We suggest that you talk with both a Fidelity workplace financial advisor and your current investment advisor.  

  • There are various kinds of annuities, including variable and fixed. Some kinds of annuities cannot be transferred into other kinds of investments without making withdrawals over multiple years. For example, if you have money in the TIAA traditional fixed guaranteed annuity account, you cannot withdraw or transfer this fund except over a 10-year installment period.
  • Always assess fees you’ve paid and will continue to pay to own an annuity if you leave your annuity with Corebridge, TIAA or the MetLife product with Fidelity – you may be surprised at how the fees add up and erode the income you’d otherwise have for retirement. It’s also important to understand what features you have pre-paid for in retirement with this type of annuity investment purchased from an insurance company. It may or may not make sense for you to move your annuity to a mutual fund with Fidelity. Transferring an annuity is your choice – make the best decision for your retirement investments.

There is no undue influence in the advice you receive from Fidelity. Fidelity consultants do not make a commission based on how you invest your retirement funds. They are salaried. Their compensation is salary + bonus and the bonus component is the number of participants they serve coupled with feedback from the plan participants on their performance and service standards. Fidelity consultants do not receive commissions from any investments they advise you to participate in.

There is not a rush to decide if you want to transfer your annuities that do not move as part of the university’s transition. Your annuities can remain in place until after June, once the transition of all other university funds have been completed, unless you take specific steps to move the annuity with your current provider into mutual funds that will transfer to the new CSU fund line-up at Fidelity.

If you decide to transfer your annuity, you will need to complete specific steps and authorize signatures.

As part of this process, you will need to request specific forms from your current investment company – TIAA, Corebridge or Fidelity for the MetLife investment.

Once you complete those forms, you’ll need to submit them to Fidelity and ask a Fidelity advisor, called a workplace financial consultant, to help you with what Fidelity needs to complete the transfer. If you need assistance in transferring an annuity to Fidelity, please contact both your current investment company (TIAA, Corebridge or Fidelity for the MetLife investment) as well as a Fidelity consultant to start the transfer process.

You will need to complete forms for both Fidelity and your current investment company (TIAA or Corebridge).

  • You need to contact TIAA or Corebridge for their forms.
  • Fidelity’s form is at this link.

Once you complete all necessary forms, you’ll submit both the Fidelity form and your current company’s form to Fidelity. Information about where to submit the forms is on the Fidelity form, linked above.


QUESTIONS TO ASK

Before you decide if you want to transfer annuities from Corebridge, TIAA or the MetLife fund at Fidelity to a mutual fund at Fidelity, here’s a checklist of questions to ask your current financial advisor AND to ask a Fidelity advisor.

Ask your current financial advisor

  • What kind of annuity do I have?
  • Can I move my account out of the annuity into a mutual fund product with your company so it will transfer to Fidelity in June?
  • How is my retirement advisor compensated when they give me advice on what investments to select? Will they lose commissions if I move my annuity? Where is this disclosed to me?
  • Can I transfer these annuities in a lump sum or is there a transfer time frame that requires a certain number of years to fully liquidate the account?
  • What fees would I be required to pay to transfer my annuity or annuities? Is there a surrender fee associated with a transfer? When does the surrender fee go away?
  • What ongoing or regular fees am I currently being charged and will continue to be charged if I do not transfer my annuity or annuities?
  • What advice do you have regarding the tradeoffs and benefits of a transfer given my current age and retirement horizon?
  • What are the risks of investing in an annuity and what is the financial rating of my current insurance annuity product?
  • What are the specifics of how my annuity has performed, including how my investment has grown over time?
  • Does my annuity have a current death benefit value I will give up if I transfer my account to Fidelity?
  • If I decide to transfer my annuity to a mutual fund at Fidelity, what are the exact steps I need to take? Are there deadlines I need to know about? What forms does your company require?

Ask a Fidelity consultant

  • Are there any extra fees I will be charged by Fidelity if I transfer my annuities to a mutual fund with Fidelity?
  • What advice do you have regarding the tradeoffs and benefits of an annuity transfer based upon my specific circumstance, timeline to retirement and fees I’m paying?
  • If I transfer my annuity to a mutual fund at Fidelity, how am I taxed on withdrawals or income from my account at retirement?
  • If I decide to transfer my annuity to a mutual fund at Fidelity, what are the exact steps I need to take to do so? Are there deadlines I need to know about?
  • Do I need to complete specific steps for Fidelity?
  • If I transfer investments to a Fidelity mutual fund, how do you and Fidelity get paid? What are my account management fees?
  • How long does it take to complete a transfer?

Annuity vs Mutual Funds 101


What is an annuity?

An annuity is an insurance company investment that will pay you a fixed amount of money each year after you retire. A retirement annuity pays you income every year for a stated time frame or until you are deceased. You have paid extra fees for this benefit.

What is a mutual fund?

A mutual fund is a pool of money with multiple investors who collectively buy stocks, bonds and other investments. The CSU high-quality investment menu at Fidelity consists of mutual funds. Mutual funds are generally less expensive than annuities.

Are there special considerations to keep in mind when you invest in an annuity?

Annuities are often more expensive than mutual funds because of a guaranteed payment feature.

As you consider whether to move an annuity to the new investment structure, you should review the fees and historical performance of your annuity and compare them to the mutual fund investment options available under the new investment line-up from CSU at Fidelity. The cumulative effect of annuity fees and expenses can substantially reduce the growth of retirement savings over time.    

How will my fees change if I do not transfer an annuity?

See the fees information page.


Who do I contact at Fidelity to discuss my CSU retirement fund options?

Samuel Casad is a Fidelity consultant who has been dedicated to CSU retirement accounts for many years. At Fidelity, their consultants are called workplace financial consultants. 

Sam and an entire team of qualified Fidelity consultants will help you during this transition – and will help you determine if moving your annuities may benefit you.

These consultants will be available virtually and at locations across the CSU main campus. There are many Fidelity Investor Centers across the country where you can walk in and meet with an advisor, including a location in Fort Collins.  

You can schedule an appointment with Samuel Casad or another Fidelity expert online at getguidance.fidelity.com.